torrent films

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

woensdag 23 mei 2012

Frank Herbert's Dune

Posted on 05:01 by john maikal
I'd first heard of Dune when I was in middle school. There was some magazine distributed at our school which described the book and the upcoming movie - I believe this was in 1983 - I do remember it was a while until the movie finally came out. I also remember it was one of those movies I wanted to see in the theaters but never managed to. My parents got me a movie tie-in novelization (same text as the classic novel but with a cover from the film) but I never managed to get too deep into it.

Several years later, during my sophomore year of college at UConn, I was looking for a new book to read at the co-op. At the time my taste in fiction wasn't too spectacular, being dominated by Star Trek novels and the novels TSR put out. Still enjoyed Stephen King, though he was unfairly in the ghetto of "genre writers". Wanting something different, I decided to splurge on a new copy of Dune, my original copy some sixty miles away at my parents' house. This time it truly clicked for me. Not only that but it unleashed a fury of classic science fiction and fantasy reading. I devoured all six of the Dune novels in short order and then worked my way to Asimov, Heinlein, Bradbury, etc. During my fifth year (my time at UConn stretched out due to taking time off to co-op) I took a science fiction class which exposed me more writers. But it all started with Dune.

With that introduction, let's take a look at the novel itself. It is a coming-of-age story, about Paul Atreides, heir-apparent to his father Duke Leto Atreides' fief of Caladan. As the book begins Duke Leto Atreides has been granted a great prize, the fief of Arrakis, also known as Dune. Arrakis, a desert planet, is the only place in the galaxy where the spice melange, which grants prophetic visions and is required for there to be any hyperspace travel. The Atreides are to replace their enemies, the Harkonnen family.

Duke Leto correctly recognizes it is a trap, one designed to destroy him and his house but he takes his family there nonetheless, the alternative being becoming a rogue house. He is also determined to succeed. It is not giving much away to reveal that he fails in this effort. However, owing to his training and generations upon generations of selective breeding, his son Paul manages to survive and becomes one of the natives of the desert, the "fremen".

It's best not to discuss much more of the plot. Rather it is the setting we will discuss. This is an old, very old empire.It takes place at least ten thousand years in the future to judge by the dates being used. The setting is shaped by the "Butlerian Jihad" which, per the book's glossary, was:
[T]he crusade against computers, thinking machines, and conscious robots begun in 201 B.G and concluded in 108 B.G. Its chief commandment remains in the O.C. [Orange Catholic] Bible as "Thou shalt not make a machine in the likeness of a human mind."
Everything about the setting is informed by this Jihad. Most have translated this crusade as a war against machine overlords and as I understand it the novels written by Frank Herbert's son Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson took this approach. I don't know if this was Frank Herbert's intent but I myself always viewed this rebellion as more being an effort to reclaim humanity from its dependence on computers and machinery - something which might involve quite a bit of fighting if there were to be any disagreement on the matter.

Either way, the end result was a great evolution in humanity. It saw the creation of the Spacing Guild, a group who had a monopoly on space travel, relying on extensive physical and mental training and the prescience granted by the spice melange to navigate through hyperspace. It also saw the Bene Gesserit, a mystical sisterhood that was founded on physical and mental training that allowed them to become the "witches" of the setting. Without computers beings known as mentats came to replace them, humans trained in logic to become human computers. This is a very human book, with no alien civilizations orsuper-computers. As we'll see, this is not a technologically-impaired civilization but rather one which rejects technology that does what a thinking human can do.

The weaponry of the setting is both primitive and advanced. There are weapons such as atomic weaponry (its use forbidden by convention) along with lasers ("lasguns"). However the lasguns are near-useless as the main defense consists of shields which can block any fast attack - but a laser shot will create a nuclear explosion This has led to knife-fighting with specialized techniques -  a fast attack will be blocked by the shield, requiring attackers use slowness to penetrate the shield.


I've just touched the tip of the society. You've also got feudal houses, assassins, religious crusades, giant sandworms, elite savage warriors, stillsuits to reclaim all of a body's moisture in the desert, etc.


Though Frank Herbert is not one of D&D's "Appendix N" (inspirational reading) authors, he is still a fantastic inspiration for such games. Hopefully my description gives the impression that Dune and its sequels contain excellent material worth mining for ideas. And one need not use it for science fiction gaming - with its feudal elements and near-magic powers of the Bene Gesserit and Spacing Guild it would not be much of a stretch at all to borrow much of it for a fantasy game. And even without mining anything specific Dune gives an excellent example of what sort of fun could be had by members of a noble house. It doesn't appear in the recommended reading section for Adventurer Conqueror King System but I think it fits in with the other works there perfectly.

There's a lot of controversy about the quality of the later books in Frank Herbert's Dune series and especially for the novels written by his son Brian Herbert with Kevin J. Anderson. My own opinion is Dune is probably the best of the novels and that I personally found the next two novels, Dune Messiah and Children of Dune, to also be of excellent quality. I found the remaining three novels, God Emperor of Dune, Heretics of Dune, and Chapterhouse: Dune, to still be enjoyable but not quite up to the level of the first three. I'm definitely on the side of the fence with those who did not enjoy the later works by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson.
Dit e-mailen Dit bloggen!Delen via XDelen op Facebook
Posted in fiction, Fiction Review | No comments
Nieuwere post Oudere post Homepage

0 reacties:

Een reactie posten

Abonneren op: Reacties posten (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Hexographer RPG Software
    Fantasy and maps tend to go hand and hand. One need only look at one of the most famous works of the genre, The Hobbit to see that. That wor...
  • ProFantasy's Campaign Cartographer 3
    As I mentioned last week I view maps as something to be both functional and artistic. Last week I reviewed the Hexographer program which lea...
  • Remain Calm. Trust in Science. Atomic Robo Overview.
    My gaming group has been experimenting with Evil Hat's Atomic Robo RPG. I've been itching to try out Fate for ages. I'm somewhat...
  • RPG Review: Dungeon Crawl Classics
    The intent of the Open Game License that Wizards of the Coast released with the 3rd edition of Dungeons & Dragons was to encourage other...
  • Delta Green Fiction
    In my last post I spoke a bit about Delta Green. After posting I realized that my familiarity with Delta Green is solely through RPG supple...
  • Alternate Mythos Lenses
    HP Lovecraft's Cthulhu Mythos have had an influence on various forms of entertainment. Many episodes of Doctor Who and Star Trek have ha...
  • Frank Herbert's Dune
    I'd first heard of Dune  when I was in middle school. There was some magazine distributed at our school which described the book and the...
  • Remembering Aaron Allston
    Aaron Allston passed away this past week. Allston was a prodigious game designer and author. In the roleplaying world he was best known for ...
  • Film Review: The Warriors
    New York actor Roger Hill passed away about a week ago according to the New York Daily News . He was best known for playing Cyrus from the 1...
  • RPG Review: The Big Crime
    This post isn't a first impressions review of the new Spectrum Games RPG The Big Crime . A few disclaimers. The first is that while I...

Categories

  • 007
  • 13th Age
  • 1880s
  • 1980s
  • 1990s
  • 3.x
  • 4e
  • a game of thrones
  • aaron allston
  • about
  • ACKS
  • adnd
  • alien
  • Ancient Rome
  • animation
  • Appendix N
  • ASSH
  • Astonishing Swordsmen and Sorcerers of Hyperborea
  • atomic robo
  • balance
  • basic dnd
  • Boston Marathon
  • brp
  • bullying
  • call of cthulhu
  • capes cowls and villains foul
  • cc3
  • ccvf
  • children
  • chromebook
  • Clark Ashton Smith
  • clerics
  • cloud
  • Cold City
  • cold war
  • comics
  • computers
  • continuity
  • Corrin Empire
  • cthulhu by gaslight
  • dark dungeons
  • Dark Tower
  • DCC
  • Delta Green
  • dice
  • digital products
  • dnd
  • Doctor Who
  • dresden files
  • dungeon crawl classics
  • dying earth
  • eberron
  • education
  • espionage
  • Fantasy America
  • FASA
  • FATE
  • fiction
  • Fiction Review
  • film
  • film reviews
  • Firefly
  • gamma world
  • gaslight
  • gateway materials
  • geekiness
  • geology
  • godlike
  • grimjack
  • gun control
  • hackmaster
  • heroines
  • historical gaming
  • history
  • home campaign
  • house rules
  • HP Lovecraft
  • humor
  • jack vance
  • John Le Carré
  • Judges Guild
  • jules verne
  • Lankhmar
  • late antiquity
  • location-based adventures
  • Lord of the Rings
  • lotfp
  • maps
  • Marvel Super Heroes
  • metamorphosis alpha
  • music
  • musings
  • mutant city blues
  • narnia
  • narrative play
  • Native Americans
  • new rules
  • new school
  • new york city
  • nexus
  • non-fiction
  • oe dnd
  • One-Roll Engine
  • ORE
  • palladium
  • player control
  • politics
  • post-apocalyptic fiction
  • prometheus
  • ravenloft
  • real world
  • recruiting
  • religion
  • retcons
  • retro-clones
  • review
  • rolemaster
  • rpg review
  • rpg review world of grewyhawk
  • rpgs
  • runequest
  • Saga System
  • sandbox
  • science fiction
  • Session Writeup
  • skills
  • slavers
  • software
  • song of ice and fire
  • speed factor
  • spirit of knowledge charter school
  • star trek
  • star wars
  • Stars Without Number
  • steampunk
  • Stephen King
  • story-based adventures
  • superhero rpgs
  • superheroes
  • superman
  • swords and wizardry
  • swords and wizardry appreciation day
  • techie
  • television
  • Thanksgiving
  • the big crime
  • The Laundry
  • Tim Powers
  • time travel
  • Top Secret
  • Traveller
  • vampire: the masquerade
  • vampires
  • virtual tabletop
  • vtt
  • wild talents
  • worcester
  • world building
  • world of darkness
  • world of greyhawk
  • zombie apocalypse

Blog Archive

  • ►  2014 (8)
    • ►  juni (1)
    • ►  maart (2)
    • ►  februari (2)
    • ►  januari (3)
  • ►  2013 (39)
    • ►  december (4)
    • ►  november (1)
    • ►  oktober (1)
    • ►  september (1)
    • ►  augustus (7)
    • ►  juli (3)
    • ►  mei (2)
    • ►  april (8)
    • ►  maart (5)
    • ►  februari (3)
    • ►  januari (4)
  • ▼  2012 (81)
    • ►  december (2)
    • ►  november (3)
    • ►  oktober (3)
    • ►  september (7)
    • ►  augustus (10)
    • ►  juli (14)
    • ►  juni (14)
    • ▼  mei (18)
      • Fiction Review: I Am Legend by Richard Matheson
      • RPG Review: Dwellers of the Forbidden City
      • Fantastic Real-World Terrain
      • Frank Herbert's Dune
      • RPG Review: D&D Basic Rules (8th-11th Printing)
      • Developing a New Campaign Setting - Broad Strokes
      • Developing a New Campaign Setting - Exploring What...
      • H.P. Lovecraft's The Shadow Over Innsmouth
      • RPG Review: Call of Cthulhu 6th Edition
      • On Bullying
      • ProFantasy's Campaign Cartographer 3
      • Justin Cronin's The Passage
      • Wanted: Adventurers in Search of Treasure and Glory
      • RPG Review: Lamentations of the Flame Princess Wei...
      • Visiting Gamma World
      • Hexographer RPG Software
      • de Camp and Pratt's "The Roaring Trumpet"
      • Appendix N - Checkpoint and Thoughts
    • ►  april (10)
Mogelijk gemaakt door Blogger.

Over mij

john maikal
Mijn volledige profiel tonen